MUSICAL THEATRE
Fiddler
on the Roof, Book by Joseph Stein, Music by Jerry Bock, Lyrics by Sheldon
Harnick (Based on
the Sholem Aleichem Stories by Special Permission of Arnold Perl)
At: Her
Majesty’s Theatre, Melbourne, until 27 Dec 2026
Reviewer:
Kate Herbert
Stars: **** (4)
This review is published only on this blog. I
presented a radio review on Arts Weekly, 3MBS, Sat 7 Nov 2026. KH
 |
| Troy Sussman as Tevye-image Daniel Boud |
This
Australian production of Fiddler on the Roof, based on the acclaimed UK
production that began
its life at Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre before transferring to the Barbican
in London, is an exceptional piece of musical theatre. Retaining the original
production concept, it combines striking design, glorious music, moving
storytelling and vivacious, skilfully executed choreography. The result is a
richly textured and emotionally affecting production that does justice to this
much-loved musical.
Joseph
Stein’s book vividly evokes the close-knit world of the Jewish shtetl, bringing
its inhabitants to life through sharply drawn characters, intimate family
relationships and the tensions between tradition and change. Jerry Bock’s
evocative score draws on the musical colours and rhythms of Eastern European
Jewish and Russian folk traditions, with its exuberant dance music, soulful
melodies and haunting lyricism capturing both the vitality and vulnerability of
this community. Sheldon Harnick’s witty, perceptive lyrics illuminate
individual characters and relationships, revealing the humour, affection,
conflict and heartbreak beneath the villagers’ everyday exchanges. Together,
book, music and lyrics create a richly human portrait of a community on the
brink of upheaval.
Tom Scutt’s striking
and deceptively simple design establishes the visual world of the impoverished
Jewish shtetl with a distinctive theatrical aesthetic, creating an evocative
setting for the villagers' domestic lives, celebrations and eventual
displacement. A floating “ceiling” over the villagers encloses and entraps them
in their shtetl. The design cunningly incorporates massed sheaves of wheat that
reference the location of the fictional village of Anatevka in the wheat belt,
the breadbasket of Russia that is now Ukraine.
 |
| Fiddler-on-the-Roof-Melbourne-2026-image Daniel Boud |
The
evocative visual elements complement Jordan Fein’s deft and detailed direction
and Julia Cheng’s remarkable, vivacious and athletic choreography, which brings
energy and precision to the ensemble sequences. The famous bottle dance, in
which the men perform complex movements while balancing huge wine bottles on
top of their hats, elicited a roar of appreciation from the audience on opening
night.
The
Australian cast delivers a fine performance, led by Troy Sussman as Tevye, a
doughty and sympathetic patriarch struggling to support his family on the
meagre income from selling milk from his cow. Sussman captures Tevye’s bluster,
humour, stubborn adherence to tradition and mounting frustration and despair as
his daughters challenge his expectations of marriage and family life.
He leads the
ensemble in rousing renditions of Tradition, If I Were a Rich Man
and several other familiar songs that are irresistible singalong material.
Sussman also handles Tevye’s direct addresses to the audience with warmth and
comic timing, frequently turning to God – who seems to reside somewhere above
the stage – for advice and consolation.
Alexis
Fishman is in fine voice as his beleaguered wife, Golde. Their three eldest
daughters are played with considerable vocal and performance skill. Freya
Boltman is engaging as Tzeitel, who chooses the local tailor, Motel, over the
considerably wealthier but elderly butcher, Lazar Wolf (John Waters). Ellen
Ebbs brings warmth to Hodel, who falls for a political radical, while Caity
Plummer is affecting as Chava, whose marriage outside the Jewish community
provokes Tevye’s deepest anguish. The role of Yente, the village matchmaker, is
an unforgiving one, and Sigrid Thornton seems an unlikely casting.
One of the
production’s extraordinary highlights is Ben Adler as the eponymous Fiddler,
whose evocative presence provides a haunting, musical counterpoint to the
unfolding drama. No spoilers here, but his first appearance at the very start
of the show, is astounding.
Although it
is set in 1905 in a Jewish shtetl in what was then Tsarist Russia, the story
feels remarkably relevant today. Beneath the humour and exuberant musical
numbers, lies a profoundly moving story about displacement, religious identity,
family and the fragility of belonging. The final pogrom forces the villagers
from their homes, scattering them into the diaspora, towards Poland, America
and elsewhere.
Fiddler
on the Roof reminds us
that tradition may provide stability, but it cannot always withstand the forces
of history.
By Kate
Herbert
 |
| Fiddler-on-the-Roof-Melbourne_To Life_2026-image Daniel Boud |
Creative
Team
Based on the
Sholem Aleichem stories, by special permission of Arnold Perl.
Book: Joseph
Stein
Music: Jerry Bock
Lyrics: Sheldon Harnick
Director: Jordan Fein
Choreographer: Julia Cheng
Designer: Tom Scutt
Resident Director (Aust): Gary Abrahams
Cast
Troy
Sussman as Tevye
Sigrid
Thronton as Yente
John
Waters as Lazar Wolf
Alexis
Fishman as Golde
Freya
Boltman as Tzeitel
Ellen
Ebbs as Hodel
Caity
Plummer as Chava
Ben
Adler as The Fiddler
Ensemble:
Maxwell Simon, Felix Star, Jacob Steen, Ritchie Singer, Danielle Barnes, Nina
Carmen, Romy Juliette Glass, Ksenia Teliatnikova, Andrew Dunne, Damien
Bermingham, Mark Doggett, Rubin Matters, Anthony Sheppard, Patrick Whitbread,
Alex Mulcahy, Nick Brown, Samantha Stewart, Hanlon Innocent, and Christopher
Tendai.