MUSICAL
THEATRE
Book
& Lyrics by Shalin McKenna and Matthew Warchus, adapted from JRR Tolkien’s
novels
Music by
A.R. Rahman, Värttinä & Christopher Nightingale
At Comedy
Theatre, Melbourne, until 8 June 2025
Stars: ***1/2 (3.5)
This review is published only on this blog. I’ll
present a radio review on Arts Weekly on 3MBS on Sat 3 May 2025. KH
 |
| Lord of the Rings, Melbourne cast |
The Lord
of the Rings – A Musical Tale, is an ambitious and vivacious stage adaptation
of J.R.R Tolkien’s beloved novels that brings Middle-Earth to life through a
creative fusion of music, song, puppetry, projections, illusions and movement.
As the audience enters the theatre to take its seats, a crowd of Hobbits sing and romp cheerfully on stage and rove amongst the audience, adding a lively pre-beginning to the production.
With
direction by Paul
Hart, the
multi-talented cast of actor-singer-dancers performs with energy and conviction
and many also play instruments for the folk music infused score, giving the
production a vibrant texture.
Puppetry
is used to striking effect, especially in the depiction of the Dark Riders.
These ghostly, spectral horses are genuinely haunting, gliding across the stage
with eerie elegance and creating some of the most memorable visuals in the
show. The giant spider in Act Two is less successful.
Among the
performances, Laurence Boxhall as Gollum is a show-stealer. Played with muscular
physicality and a guttural, disturbing vocal tone, the character’s split
personality is compelling and deeply unsettling. Although it is clearly
inspired by Andy Serkis’s iconic film portrayal, Boxhall brings it to life with
his unique stage presence.
Rarmian
Newton as Frodo Baggins, the Hobbit, provides a strong emotional core to the
story as he journeys not only over Middle-Earth but from naivete to strength
and courage. Frodo is tasked with taking the Ring to the Fires of Mordor, and
he carries this burden of the Ring with vulnerability and resolve.
Terence
Crawford’s Gandalf is suitably majestic and authoritative, providing moments of
warmth, wisdom and startling magic throughout the journey. Jemma Rix brings
power and beauty to Galadriel, the Elvish queen, and her appearance and song
were highlights. Rob Mallett’s Aragorn is
compelling, dignified and rich-voiced.
The production
is successful in many ways, but there are some noticeable issues.
The staging
is overly cluttered at times and, although some of the choreography (Anjali Mehra) is effective, other dance and
movement routines feel amateurish or awkward and do not serve the narrative or
characters. Galadriel's appearance lacks the elvish magic she deserves, and her costume is disappointing; it looked like a gold, 70s jump suit!
The Elvish
characters’ dance moves lean oddly into 1960s hippy territory, undermining the
mystical, ethereal quality often associated with elves in Tolkien’s world.
While not
without its flaws, The Lord of the Rings – A Musical Tale is a bold and
heartfelt retelling of Tolkien’s classic. It may take creative liberties, but
its ambition and moments of theatrical magic make it a production worth
experiencing.
KATE HERBERT
Cast
Laurence Boxhall as Gollum
Andrew Broadbent as Elrond
Hannah Buckley as Pippin
Stefanie Caccamo as Arwen
Rohan Campbell as Boromir
Jeremi Campese as Merry
Ruby Clark as Rosie
Terence Crawford as Gandal
Wern Mak as Samwise Gamgee
Rob Mallett as Strider
Connor Morel as Gimli
Rarmian Newton as Frodo Baggins
Conor Neylon as Legolas
Jemma Rix as Galadriel
Ian Stenlake as Saruman
Ensemble: Georgia Anderson, Gianna Cheung, Nicholas
Cunningham, Cameron Davey, Natasha Dumlao, James
Frampton, Anthony Garcia, Jonathan Gardner, Matt
Hourigan, Esther Lukins, Jayme Jo Massoud, Patrick Schnur, James
Whiting and Zayneb Zerzouri.
Creative
Team
Director
– Paul Hart
Musical
Direction – Andrew Bevis
Choreographer
& Movement Director – Anjali Mehra
Lighting
Designer- Rory Beaton
Projection
Designer - George Reeve
Original
Sound Designer - Adam Fisher
Fight
director – Dani McCallum
Puppet
Designer – Charlie Tymms
Magic
& Illusions – Adam Mada