Saturday, 21 November 2026

One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest_REVIEW_17Nov2026

  

THEATRE

One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest by Dale Wasserman, based on the novel by Ken Kesey

At Athenaeum Theatre until Sun 20 Dec 2026

Reviewer: Kate Herbert

Stars: *** ½ (3.5)

This review is published only on this blog. I presented a radio review on Arts Weekly, 3MBS, Sat 21 Nov 2026. KH

Jason Donovan, NAdine Garner pic Eugene Hyland

 

One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest is heartbreaking, uplifting, moving and very funny. It raises uncomfortable and painful questions, challenges our perceptions of the world and, most importantly, makes us care deeply about these damaged and vulnerable characters.

 

Roger Hodgman deftly directs this production of Dale Wasserman’s play, based on Ken Kesey’s novel. Set in a men’s psychiatric ward that is starkly realised in Richard Roberts’ clinical design, it becomes a battle of wills between newly arrived, rebellious and confrontational patient Randall P. McMurphy (Jason Donovan) and the coldly tyrannical Nurse Ratched (Nadine Garner). 

 

They wrestle for control of the hearts and minds of the incarcerated men, as well as their freedom. McMurphy may be belligerent and antagonistic, but some of Ratched’s rules are onerous, punitive and even inhumane. Punishment, after all, has never been an effective cure for mental illness.

 

What shocks McMurphy, in more ways than one, is discovering that many of these men are voluntary patients. They have been persuaded that Nurse Ratched has their best interests at heart and that, under her supervision, they will eventually be cured. For some, the outside world is more frightening than their institutional existence. It is a sad indictment of a society in which these men feel safer incarcerated than free.

 

Donovan is nuggety, muscular and in perpetual motion as McMurphy, a bolshy, uninhibited rule-breaker with little impulse control. He mistakenly believes that being committed to the hospital will be an easier ride than serving the final five months of his prison sentence. With his mischievous, playful and provocative antics, he rouses the men from their torpor, challenging the numbing effects of medication, ennui and despair.

 

Cast of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest _pic_Eugene Hyland 

Accustomed to being a lovable top dog, McMurphy assumes that the rules of the outside world, or even the prison, will apply here. But there is a different pecking order in this institution, and he is certainly not at the top.

 

Nadine Garner plays Nurse Ratched with an unnervingly controlled composure. Her ever-present, concerned smile occasionally threatens to become a sneer, barely concealing the manipulative control and disdain beneath it. She is a formidable adversary, wielding institutional authority with an almost chilling sense of benevolence.

 

Jeremy Proulx is compelling and sympathetic as Chief Bromden, the quiet observer of the ward's daily machinations. A physically imposing Native American man, Chief has been diminished and silenced by the treatment of white colonisers and corporate marauders who have dispossessed his people of their ancestral land. His apparent muteness conceals a powerful inner life.

Jason Donovan, Jeremy Proulx _pic_Eugene Hyland

David James plays Dale Harding, the articulate and intelligent patients' representative, while Daniel R. Nixon portrays the emotionally fragile, stuttering young Billie Bibbit with considerable pathos.

 

Among the other patients, Chris Connolly's Ruckley is particularly disturbing, having apparently chosen to be metaphorically 'nailed' to the wall. John Xintaveonis's Martini, meanwhile, provides some wonderfully absurd moments with his hallucinations, even waving at individuals in the audience.

 

The play explores power dynamics, the individual versus the institution, social repression and oppression, and the treatment of people with mental illness. It also interrogates our understanding of sanity and insanity, while challenging conventional attitudes towards masculinity and sexuality.

 

There is considerable humour here, but it is underpinned by an unsettling awareness of the vulnerability of those who have surrendered their autonomy to an institution that purports to care for them.

 

This is a challenging, entertaining and ultimately affecting production that leaves us questioning who, in this world, is really sane.

 

By Kate Herbert

 

CAST

Jason Donovan – Randall P. McMurphy
Nadine Garner – Nurse Ratched
Jeremy Proulx – Chief Bromden
Harvey Almond – Dr Spivey
Martin Blum – Scanlon
Chris Connolly – Ruckley / Aide Turkle
Mia Dabrowski-Chandler – Nurse Flynn / Sandra
Darcey Eagle – Candy Starr
Gyton Grantley – Cheswick
David James – Dale Harding
Daniel R. Nixon – Billie Bibbit
Jack Scott – Aide Williams
Deep Sroa – Aide Warren
John Xintaveonis – Martini

CREATIVE TEAM

Roger Hodgman – Director
Richard Roberts – Set Designer
Ella Butler – Costume and Hair Designer
Kohan Van Sambeek – Original Music
Niklas Pajanti – Lighting Designer
Marcello Lo Ricci – Sound Designer

 

No comments:

Post a Comment