Sunday, 2 October 1994

Rigoletto by Theatreworks, 2 Oct 1994

 


Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 2 October 1994

This review was published in the Melbourne Times after 2 October 1994

 

Theatreworks’ Rigoletto is an adaptation of Victor Hugo's Amusing the King, the precursor to Verdi's opera. Director, Robert Draffin, has stirred a hotpot of performance and musical styles together.

 

There are stretches of Verdi's Rigoletto, particularly La Donna e’ Mobile which becomes almost a tragic signature tune for Rigoletto's skateboard ride downhill, and chunks of hilarious club comedy, slapstick and black Berlin cabaret which has echoes of the darkness of Franz Wedekind's Lulu plays.

 

There is something amiss in the world of Rigoletto. He inhabits a world of darkness and deformity, being a hunchback in a hostile environment but he also lives as Jester to the King and is invested with the questionable role of amusing His Majesty with entertaining quips and women to be violated.

 

Strangely, in spite of the dreadful train of events facing Rigoletto and his virginal daughter (Antoinette Halloran) it was the two outsiders to the action who seemed to generate the greatest emotional impact. Heather Bolton's club singer reeked of failure and angst while her every facial twitch commented upon the fate of Rigoletto. Hugh Wayland as the musician and hired killer provided an amoral eye and a wry, critical presence on the sidelines.

 

The classical arias are counterpointed against piano accordion, intoning, clamorous dialogue and modern torch songs sung by Maddalena, (Heather Bolton) a dissolute, dejected and drunken club singer. There is an appropriate desperation and anguish in the at times near-cacophonous soundscape.

 

The content is eclectic and Draffin has employed a style which relies heavily on held moments, silences and intense gazes to heighten the dramatic tension. Characters step in and out of spotlights like rabbits in headlights. While one character is in focus, others cruise the perimeter of the space, disappear behind swathes of red velvet curtaining, tinkle at the piano or sit drinking and smoking a nightclub table drinking. There is always an observer of the action.

 

 Merfyn Owen is a delightfully eccentric, bitter and pained Rigoletto who can carry the classical singing as well as the stand-up comedy routines which he does in his anachronistic nightclub context. Ian Scott has a resonance and power as the immoral and indulged King who parades about his kingdom.

 

Considering the actual horror of the moment, I found the tragic ending surprisingly unmoving. Theatrically and visually it was powerful, but the production leaves us somehow emotionally disconnected from Rigoletto. The emphasis on the music leaves little space for development of the characters and their relationships. In an opera with a full orchestra the thinness of the narrative is compensated by the swell of the orchestral score. This Rigoletto rests somewhere between the two forms of opera and theatre and has yet to successfully blend the two.

 

This work is very new, exciting and has some extraordinary theatrical moments which will certainly develop as the season progresses. It's worth seeing.

 

By Kate Herbert

Friday, 16 September 1994

Cross Arts & Movement Program, Fringe 94, 16 Sept 1994

Cross Arts and Movement Program, Melbourne Fringe Festival 1994

Writer: Kate Herbert around 16 September 1994

This review was published in the Melbourne Times after 16 September 1994

 

 

Hybrid Arts, Cross Arts. Whatever you call these multi-art works, Fringe artists are notorious for slinging several art forms into the one scruffy package. You can lump dance, sculpture, cyber-machines, computer graphics, text, music, noise, dirt and costumes into an hour-long phantasmagoria. It might be spectacular. It could really suck.

 

I reckon the press releases tell you plenty about who's an artsy wanker and who's a real artist so here are a few excerpts.

 

Circus Soup calls itself "an action-packed night of music and marvels...with groove engineers and circus performers." I'm inclined to believe this one because it has Sam Angelico, a class mime and magic act, Matthew Hughes from Circus Oz who is hot, and Oxo Cubans who are a groovy band with a singer who has a haircut like a muffin. ($16 & $12)

 

Serious contemporary dance fiends should get along to Danceworks is back with a revamped Physical Business from '93 ($10 & $15). I don't know the dancers but you could try at the Women's Gallery for three solo female dance works or see the dance-doco The Road to Be-Bop which asks you to bring beret, dark glasses and a Beat attitude.

 

The Dancehouse program takes us back into hybrid arts with a program comprising dance, videos, performances, discussions and a visual art exhibition as a bonus. Mary Madigan wins prizes for best title: Read my Hips ($8) which has "drawings, movement and social change" and a very esoteric press release.

 

Students from Change studio in None of the Above are demonstrating dance and other "Afro-techno synchronised fire club swinging" stuff. Seriously! I'm quoting! ($9.50 & $7.50) Take a fire extinguisher.

 

The Newry Pub's Frenzy says "Enjoy a quiet drink" with your poetry, art and music. It's free!! Ghost in the Machine cites the use of movement and "interactive computer environments". You can get close to virtual reality with this show if you're having trouble with actual reality - which most of Fitzroy and St. Kilda do.

 

Look out for Leather Butoh , a cyber-inspired performance art group." Yikes! Suzuki stompin', machine grindin', computer groovin' cyber artists in black leather!! Don't you get scared when they're so seriously groovy? And when they use the word "installation" instead of "exhibition"?

 

Butoh features again in Butchyaketa's Crack. ($13 & $9). We seem to have a plethora of artists who crave dark Japanese angst-ridden movement in our middle-class Western environment. More praise to 'em.

But my pick for a big old hoot, is Dance of the Desert which boasts belly dancers with a band at a Turkish restaurant. Now that sounds like exotic fun for a gaggle of your friends.

 

Kate Herbert

Fringe Festival Melbourne 1994 -OVERVIEW- 16 Sept 1994

 

Fringe Festival Melbourne 1994

Writer: Kate Herbert around 16 September 1994

This review was published in the Melbourne Times after 16 September 1994

 

If you're not on your toes during a Fringe Festival, you could end up paying good eating money to watch someone smash bottles while standing screaming knee-deep in a puddle while someone wearing black pours pig's blood on her head. So let's put you in the picture quick smart so you don't get your fingers burnt and your wallet rifled.

 

35 plus theatre productions are listed in the Melbourne Fringe program ranging from established companies (IRAA, Theatreworks), through known local professionals (Shirley Billing, Ross Daniels, The Pidds), to international artists, interstate plays and cabarets, student shows and complete wild card unknowns which are always a risk but sometimes a gift.

 

Venues range from a student show at the Dodgem Hall at Luna Park, Last Laugh, North Melbourne Town Hall, Galleries, studios in Alphington and Fitzroy, Mechanics' Institute and the Builders' Arms Pub.

 

There are real theatres too, like Gasworks, The Universal which has zillions of shows, The Courthouse, La Mama which is three-deep again in its inimitable festival overkill form, Napier Street, St, Martins, National Theatre, and Theatreworks which is still getting shows on in spite of the ill-will of the nasty Church guardians.

 

Here's what I'd see. In the funny physical Theatre list The King's Player by Trevor Gare looks terrific. He uses European clown technique as a bit-player in Hamlet, David and Ian are finally doing Rawsharking, a comic, circusy show with music about doppelgangers.

 

Harry Cripps’ White Paris which will be black comedy in the vein of his Tania and Kit. Theatreworks Rigoletto is rampant, wild-eyed musical grotesguery. Cop Theatre Tarquin's adaptation of Franz Kafka's The Trial which should have Nick Harrington's usual innovation and blackness.  All Hopeless Romantics should see Theatre Zart doing Love's Idiotic Triangle, an adaptation of Dostoyevski's The Idiot.

 

We have an international contingent this year. Don't miss the three shows IRAA is sponsoring for their Austrian guest artists. Alt / Tag looks like something Handspan would do, with an 80-year-old female puppet in an existential dilemma about age. Otto Lechner is a magical musician who takes you on adventures with The Dark Side of the (Piano) Accordion.

 

La Mama is up to its little rafters with shows. Fairytales from the Future looks like violent, romantic fairy tales with a great cast including Maud Davy and Robert Lyon. Trampoline is a multi-media piece about the "The Great Earth Mother", and Her Mother's Daughter is by a German playwright, Chris Paul.

 

The Fringe Showcase replacing Short Works and Women's Season, invariably has one hot piece for a bunch of dogs but it’s cheap and short. Most tickets are from $10 to $17 but La Mama is a bargain from $6 to $12 max. Fringe Artists get discounts.

 

Go book now!

 

 

KATE HERBERT

Sunday, 21 August 1994

My Body My Blood, by Margaret Kirby, 21 Aug 1994

THEATRE

At Chapter House St. Paul's Cathedral, Melbourne, Mon-Sat 7.30 pm until Sept 10, 1994

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 21 Aug 1994

This review was published in the Melbourne Times after 21 Aug 1994

 

Margaret Kirby's new play, My Body My Blood, , directed by Marcia Ferguson, investigates the attitude of the Anglican Church to women in religious roles, a profoundly emotional area of debate still raging in the church and the women's movement. A quote in the play from an ancient order of nuns, tells the story clearly. "Did they make it hard for you too? Did you fight? Were you strong?"

 

Mary (Tammy McCarthy) is deeply affected by the death of her friend and mentor Beatrice (Brenda Palmer), a deaconess desperate for the church to recognise her "priestliness". Mary questions her own relationships with church and family. Flashbacks draw parallels with 17th century women battling male prejudice, accusations of witchery, and denial of their healing skills.

 

The acoustics are appalling but generally actors dealt with the problem. There were some glorious solo, choral and canon singing which established the poignant, melancholy flavour of a mind in religious turmoil. I wanted more. The script screams for atmosphere.

 

This is not a serious and self-important script, although at times it lapses into religious polemic. It is peppered with funny observations about character, religion, gender and power. Sliced white bread and cooking sherry are used for an improvised communion and the absurdity of the whole gender argument is highlighted when an early Christian bishop simply changes "Julia" to "Julius" when confronted with a woman apostle in the Bible.

 

The ensemble is strong but the fraught verbal battles between two sisters, Mary and Martha, were the highlights for me. McCarthy is suitably addled and passionate as the heavily pregnant and religiously questing Mary but my accolades are saved for Maud Davy who is warm, eccentric and scintillating as her prim and subservient sister, Martha.

 

Scene changes to 17th century England are confusing and slow, which seems to be a production rather than a script problem. It needs clearer shifts in accent, space, lighting; something to give substance and clarity to the flashbacks.

 

The choice to perform in the woody, candle-lit interior of the Chapter House at St. Paul's Cathedral was inspired. The action has as a backdrop, enormous and imposing (in both senses of the word) portraits of Anglican bishops and audience trails upstairs past doors adorned with the nameplates of exclusively male clerics. Unfortunately, the stage design clashes radically with this environment.

 

Kate Herbert

Wednesday, 10 August 1994

Falling From Grace by Hannie Rayson, Playbox, 10 Aug 1994

THEATRE

At Playbox Merlin Theatre until August 27, 1994 then touring.

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 10 Aug 1994

This review was published in the Melbourne Times after 10 Aug 1994

 

Professional women's conversations meander from gossip to international politics, corporate work issues to romantic disasters - all in a nano-second; confusing for outsiders, namely men.  

 

Falling From Grace, Hannie Rayson's new play for Playbox, is uncannily accurate in representing the worlds of four modern women fighting forty who have busy, successful, complicated, often fraught professional and personal lives. The characters are never predictable but heck, are they familiar!

 

The narrative interweaves numerous threads. Central is the long-standing friendship between Suzannah (Catherine Wilkin), the editor of a smart monthly magazine and her two soul mates. The fiercely loyal Maggie (a difficult "go-between" role played warmly by Deirdre Rubenstein) and Brock (a feisty Diane Smith), a committed and pregnant journalist who shirtfronts the world.

 

A medical research project, led by a respected gynaecologist, Miriam Roth, (played with majesty by Belinda Davey) comes under fire from Suzannah's wet and guilt-mongering ex-husband (Sean Scully) and the magazine is faced with ruining a woman's career if they print a profile on Miriam and her research.

 

Performances are, without exception, extraordinarily skilful. Roger Oakey makes a meal of his role as Michael: lawyer, lover and "loyal but unfaithful" husband. Wilkin bounds from scene to scene in an emotional and moral mine field with her detailed and prismatic portrayal of Suzannah.

 

There is more, much more to the story. Secrets, loyalties, prejudices, deceptions all elucidate the dilemma, "To print or not to print". Each character's moral position is discoloured by his or her personal relationships. Everybody acts irresponsibly, childishly and selfishly at some point, but the major issue is the degree of trust women place in their friends and the damage a breach of faith can cause.

 

The brief scenes require frequent set changes which, thanks to Trina Parker's light, effective design and Aubrey Mellor's brisk and economical direction, move efficiently.

 

Dialogue is astringent, witty and economical. Some longer, more didactic speeches slowed the action but raised moral and ethical points. The numerous plot threads took some time to resolve in a longish second act but Falling from Grace maintains the tenor of warmth and honesty which permeates Rayson's writing. She is a jewel in our crown, a Victorian State treasure.

 

KATE HERBERT

 

 

Friday, 15 July 1994

Blood Brothers, Melbourne, 17 July 1994

At Comedy Theatre, Melbourne from July 15, 1994

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 15 July 1994

This review was published in the Melbourne Times after 15 July 1994

 

Twins are known to have an uncanny bond, and those separated at birth experience a pervasive and perpetual sense of loss. Willy Russell's Tony award-winning musical, Blood Brothers, has two such boys at its heart.

 

One twin, Eddie (Ross Girven) is illegally adopted by an infertile but wealthy woman, while Mickey (Stefan Dennis) remains with his Liverpool mother who pops a babe a year. In spite of their mothers' attempts keep them apart, the boys become intimate friends, blood brothers for life - and to the death.

 

David Soul of Starsky and Hutch fame, has a potent stage presence and rich voice as the doomsaying bogeyman, the portentous Narrator who speaks their fates. Delia Hannah is exceptional as the boys' superstitious mother, with a powerful voice and warm, unaffected style.

 

Stefan Dennis meets her level as the tragic working-class boy. He has perfected every detail and mannerism of a boy at 8 and 14 and is totally credible. His performance is warm, funny, accurate and, by the final scenes, his character is truly heart-breaking. Ross Girven and Tina Regtien are charming as his twin, and his girlfriend.

 

The first act of Blood Brothers is light, entertaining, but a little slow. After interval though, all stops are out. The songs are more singable, the narrative weightier, the plot shifting away from melodrama to genuine drama and, finally, to tragedy. Russell, writer of Educating Rita and Shirley Valentine, has injected a rare depth into this musical.

 

The chorus is strong, but John Wraight stands out in several hilarious, broad comic cameos. The invisible live band was terrific. The music and lyrics also by Russell, range from the pedestrian to the hummable to the invigorating.  Dennis's yearning song "Long Sunday Afternoon" is charming and "Bright New Day" was a fine joyful ending to Act One.

 

"Tell Me It's Not True", sung movingly by Hannah and company, capped off this tear-jerker. Take a box of tissues for the finale. This is a real weeper.

 

KATE HERBERT    

Wednesday, 13 July 1994

Underwear, Perfume and Crash Helmet by Michael Gurr, 13 July 1994

 

By Playbox Theatre

At Beckett Theatre, Southbank until August ( No definite close)

 Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 13 July 1994

This review was published in the Melbourne Times after 13 July 1994

 

Underwear, Perfume and Crash Helmet deals with numerous issues, none of which is in the title. Directed stylishly by Bruce Myles, Michael Gurr's latest play for Playbox has a profusion of ideas, a litany of pithy social observations and myriad peculiar characters, but it never lights on any one topic. The writing is often witty and riddled with glib and cynical one-liners about politics, grief, loss, madness, but the content remains insubstantial and the narrative unaffecting.

 

Director, Bruce Myles, creates a strong, portentous atmosphere and uses a powerful theatrical device, scattering the stage with actors who remain on stage like voyeurs or critics, even if they are not in the action, observing, responding or ignoring it. Stuart Greenbaum's music supports the mood and Glen Hughes lighting is grim and stark against a fine expressionist backdrop by Judith Cobb. This extremely talented team creates an atmosphere which gives some weight to a rather emotionless text.

 

The play is a collage of scenes hanging like coats on a rack, but it is not an abstract, non-narrative script. An Australian Liberal member dies near an election, so Blair, a party worker-bee (Penelope Stewart) promotes the MP's hapless and politically incompetent wife Caroline (Janet Andrewartha) as a candidate. Lionel, (John Gregg), a globe-trotting Canadian speaker on conservative politics, assists Caroline to parliament. He is accompanied by an obnoxious valet-come- psychopath (Simon Wilton) who befriends Nick, Caroline's taciturn, saxaphone-playing brother (David Tredinnick).

 

An eccentric and seemingly irrelevant sub-plot revolves around Michelle, a loopy, homeless girl (Tammy Mc Carthy) and "True Believer" in aliens who will come to take her "Home". She is the key to the violent and peculiar climax and provides tenuous parrallels for a couple of themes: Caroline's craving for "Home", and the blind faith of the "True Believers" in politics both of which remain largely unexplored.

 

With such a plethora of narrative threads and characters, many issues are left dangling like Lionel's ties. Before interval, it was a novelty piecing together the jigsaw of scenes, but the second half is less successful. It feels laboured and ponderous, having too many threads and a multiplicity of endings. The six, very skilful actors, began to look uncomfortable and uncertain.

 

 

KATE HERBERT

 

Wednesday, 6 July 1994

Me and My Girl, Revised by Stephen Fry, REVIEW, 6 July 1994=

 Music by Noel Gay, Book & Lyrics by L.A. Rose & D. Furber revised by Stephen Fry

 Produced by Adelaide Festival Theatre Trust & John Nicholls Productions.

At Princess Theatre, Melbourne, from early July 1994 (no end date)

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 5 July 1994.  

This review published in The Melbourne Times after 6 July 1994

 

Some confusion over our seats for Me and My Girl meant I was sitting on an eight-year-old, but this vulgar, old-fashioned vaudeville-style musical was worth the discomfort. It is uplifting, with fine chorus work, dreadful jokes and fabulous costumes.

 

Derek Metzger plays Bill Snibson, a dodgy cockney who is the new Earl of Harewood. Where has this exceptionally talented and stylish Kiwi been hiding? He is a fine tenor, an effortless dancer and is charming, warm, magnetic and relaxed. Metzger has that illusive "It" "Star" tattooed on his forehead.

 

Rachael Beck, as Sally, is engaging with a very pretty voice and other strong performances come from Sheila Bradley and Peter Whitford as the stuffy old Duchess and her ageing acolyte.

 

The story is simple; poor boy gets rich, loses poor girl, gets poor girl back again as rich girl. (intentional echoes of My Fair Lady) The script is light and funny: a pun-fest. "Aperitif?" asks the butler. "No thanks," says Bill, tapping his teeth. "I've got me own." Many contemporary quips are probably courtesy of Stephen Fry (of “Fry and Laurie") who has modernised what remained of the original 30's stage script.

 

Nigel West's direction of the comedy has some smart clowning and good slapstick interspersed with an overdose of tacky sexual innuendo. The tiger-skin rug coming to life in the hands of Metzger, was a treat.

 

If the words "sexual politics" make you foam at the mouth, skip this. This is the most jaw-droppingly sexist script ever. There were some nasty verbal references to women, but an early seduction scene between the lusty Lady Jacqueline and Bill, borders on offensive, making Benny Hill look like political satire.

 

The elaborate sets by Martin Johns changed so seamlessly that I missed them, and the transparent ancestors' portrait gallery was a feast. Kathy Norcross has done some lively choreography, but Lambeth Walk takes the cake. Along with Leaning on a Lamp post, it is one of the few memorable songs and is the

 

But if you are expecting, as was I, that "The bells are ringing/ For me and my girl" was the title song, you are wrong. Another show evidently. 

By Kate Herber

Thursday, 23 June 1994

Mysteries by Tom Lindstrom, REVIEW, 23 June 1994

Venue unrecorded.

Reviewer: Kate Herbert, 23 June 1994

This review published in The Melbourne Times after 23 June1994

 

Mysteries is an exceptionally funny, twisted view of the world through the psyche of the solitary, desperate and alien Edwin Cowper; a peculiar man who is amazed when others think him peculiar.

 

Tom Lindstrom's latest play, directed by Tom Gutteridge, is based loosely on Knut Hamsun's novel of 1892. The protagonist arrives in a hick country town. Both he and the town are riddled with unsolved mysteries; dislikeable young man has suicided; hunchback dances for money; Cowper's family may be murdered, abandoned or non-existent.

 

David Wicks plays Cowper with a faintly amused, quizzical and almost rapturous quality. He calls himself, cynically, a "professor of moral philosophy". Wicks is an eccentric and absorbing actor. His joyful, dynamic and constantly surprising performance often left me gasping.

 

All Cowper's conversations are somehow perverse but poetic, fascinating but disquieting in their intensity. He is a truth-sayer and a psychic with nothing to lose. Lindstrom's delicate but dense language is moulded by Wicks into some strange other-worldly creature. The two are a hot combo.

 

The comedy is often ribald or grimly amusing. I found myself laughing at farts during a funeral, and then at a gruesome, but disconcertingly hilarious, buggery scene.  Bizarre attempts to cover excruciatingly slow scene changes with mumbling actors dressed in mourning, shattered the atmosphere and drove me to distraction.

 

Minor characters are as eccentric as Cowper (pronounced "Cooper", he insists). Peter, the annoyingly obsequious hunchback (Bob Pavlich), is the butt of the whole town's scorn and was a role with more dramatic potential. A forbidding chamber maid is played with an intense watchfulness by Carole Patullo.

 

Lindstrom's subtle weaving of language, his quirky vision of reality, his portrayal of an existential dilemma, the arresting beauty of his images, all create a captivating theatrical vision.

 

Buy Kate Herbert

Wednesday, 22 June 1994

The Elocution of Benjamin Franklin by Steve J. Spears, REVIEW, MTC, 22 June 1994

At Russell Street Theatre, Melbourne, Melbourne Theatre Company (MTC)

From June to 23 July 1994

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 22 June 1994.

This review published in The Melbourne Times after 22 June 1994

 

The Elocution of Benjamin Franklin leaves one with a sense of overwhelming sadness. It traces the later career of a homosexual elocution teacher and his decline at the hands of the Australian prejudice in the 70's. The play should be called The Execution Robert O'Brien.

 

Bob Hornery is charming and tragic as the ageing transvestite and homosexual who runs The Shakespeare Speech and Drama School. The opening scenes are witty and warm, quirky and high camp. He prances about naked, sings along to Skyhooks, talks to his bust of Shakespeare and brushes his teeth. It feels intensely intimate to speak inside someone's life. We all have peculiar solitary habits and writer Steve J. Spears highlights these.

 

O'Brien closes the luxaflex venetian blinds in his Toorak flat and applies the Helena Rubenstein rouge and lippy and dons some appalling matronly gowns. His daily clandestine ritual is funny and poignant.

 

There may be only one actor, but Spears peoples the stage with characters: innumerable speech students with stammers, lisps, accents, and bad acting. Bruce, a transvestite stock broker, makes regular appearances escaping from his wife and spotty children into his fantasy world of drag with his friend, O'Brien. Apart from his confidante Shakespeare, Bruce is the only person who sticks by O'Brien through the dreadful trials which beset him.

 

The rigid morality of the time, and the high-handed attitude of the surrounding conservative Toorak society which comprised his neighbours and clients, are comic until they destroy the man. Their nasty voyeurism and accusations are counterpointed by O'Brien's concern and altruism. He is no pederast, and he advises Benjamin to try girls. "You might like them. They're soft - and they have breasts." His lust for schoolboys is strictly fantasy.

 

Spears script is a witty, detailed and deeply moving tale. The first two acts are a collage of swiftly shifting scenes with only the odd slow moment. At the start, many of the MTC audience tittered at the homosexual, transvestism and lewd references as if it were a drag show, but the stillness and profound pain of the final moments make this a bitter-sweet commentary on our treatment of "outsiders".

 

There is something of The Guildford Four in this story. While O'Brien is incarcerated, a bevy of supporters and legal eagles pursue justice for him outside, but this has no impact on his daily life.

 

This production, 20 years after the original, international hit starring Gordon Chater, has stood the test of time. Charm, wit and tragedy do not date.

By KATE HERBERT

Tuesday, 21 June 1994

Simon Palomares as Dali, Hysteria, MTC, June 21, 1994

ARTICLE

Interview with Simon Palomares (1994) 

Playing Salvador Dali in Hysteria, by Terry Johnson 

Melbourne Theatre Company  

Article by Kate Herbert for The Melbourne Times

This article published after June 21, 1994


"Salvador Dali is not just another ethnic," says Simon Palomares. "He's Spanish." Palomares, a Spanish-Australian who has recently been living between Madrid and Melbourne, plays the provocative master of surrealism in an upcoming Melbourne Theatre Company production of Terry Johnston's Hysteria.
Simon Palomares as  Dali in Hysteria, MTC, 1994
Hysteria is not a play about the mad Spaniard (I mean Dali, not Palomares), but Dali's meeting with psychoanalyst and patron saint of the surrealists, Sigmund Freud. Dali, says Palomares, visited Vienna three times to meet his idol.

"While he (Dali) was sitting in a cafe eating snails he heard that Freud had gone to London and when he walked into the house in Hampstead, the first thing he saw was a trail of snails leading to the bicycle." Very surreal and spooky according to Dali.

Rebecca S. was a famous case history of Freud's. In the play, Jessica, the daughter of Rebecca S, invades Freud's study late one wet London night to confront him about his incorrect diagnosis and treatment of her mother as an hysteric and victim of incest. Rebecca's mental deteriorated severely after treatment and her memories of abuse by her father were revealed to be inaccurate.

Johnston is reflecting the recent world-wide outcry, started in the US, against therapists who have uncovered, through hypnosis, deep memories of incest in disturbed patients. Sceptics suggest that such memory may be manufactured and therefore inaccurate. The argument rages still about therapists whose every client has the same memories of abuse. The problem arises when the experience of all incest victims is doubted.

Letters from Freud denouncing his own theory, were found in a closet in his Hampstead home after his death. They suggested that the "hysterics" may fantasise about fathers' attentions and therefore manufacture memories. These letters were used in a book by a former member of the Freudian Foundation and Terry Johnston has used Freud's last-ditch recanting as the basis of his narrative.

"Freud thought the surrealists were a pack of wankers.... He didn't believe you could put the subconscious on canvas." The meeting between the two masters was ten minutes only, but Freud, who was dying with mouth and throat cancer, was quite taken with Dali and allowed himself to be sketched.

The title of the play has its origin in the Freudian theory of hysteria. Freud posited that hysteria, an exclusively female condition according to him, was a direct result of childhood sexual abuse by the girl's father. "When Freud's theories came out pre-World War II, he was a Jew in Vienna suggesting that "the proper men of society were molesting their daughters."

He took a rapid about face when his sister, Anna, manifested symptoms of hysteria in later life and he was confronted with the impossibility of his own father's misdeeds.
Johnston is walking on fragile ice here, but his intention is not to write a dark tragic expose' on Freud's misdemeanours. The play dances blithely between broad comedy and dark surrealistic drama and the one feeds and highlights the other.

"There are parts of the play that are pure farce," says Palomares. "Doors slamming, knocking, 'Ooh, somebody's coming', getting caught in embarrassing positions. You lull the audience into a sense of 'this is what we're watching', then suddenly you start talking about child molestation and incest." Comedy and tragedy are all too close in our lives.
In Spain, he made a French-Spanish feature film, ˜Shooting Elizabeth, with Jeff Goldblum and Mimi Rogers. He played an Anglo-Saxon American. Ironically, in Spain, he always auditions for the British and American roles.

He went back to Madrid recently to write a pilot for a comedy show. The Spanish television comedy scene is evidently differs little from ours. "TV executives are the same everywhere. They think they know what people want to watch."

Given the comic elements of the script, it is obvious why director, Simon Phillips, has cast Palomares as Dali. He has worked in comedy for many years and was one of the original team which created Acropolis Now.

He has recently been in an ABC documentary about the recent development of ethnic humour in Australia, but he had reservations about being involved. "I'm sick of the subject. It doesn't mean every time you do a character who is not Australian or Anglo-Saxon that you are saying anything about Australian ethnicity."

He has separated himself from the image of "wog comic" he had a few years ago, by living overseas and doing more theatre and film work. It takes courage and creative ambition to leave such a lucrative and popular area in an industry riddle with unemployment and Palomares has gone ahead in leaps and bounds.

Choosing Dali as a character in a play about Freud is not based exclusively on his artwork and public persona. Dali was a psychotherapist's dream case; a veritable can of psychological worms.  His parents, rather morbidly, named him after a sibling who died at 18 months and the second young Salvador was regularly taken to visit a grave bearing his own name. No wonder he was a wacko!

He had been molested by a male teacher as a child. "He had a problem with intimacy," says Palomares. "Although he was a very sexually active person he never touched." In the 60's he became the guru of the hippies who lives near his Spanish home. He invited young people to his studio for orgies. "He would stand behind his canvas and masturbate rather than paint" - a charming mentor for the young.

Palomares says that if he played Dali as Dali he would be "too over-the-top" because, let's face it, the guy came across as pretty potty. Ironically, Palomares met, in Spain, people who knew Dali and who described him as " a very average person. But as soon as the camera went on or the tape recorder went on the he was off flying." He made himself a phenomenon. He could turn "Dali" on and off at will.  "He and Gala had one of the best publicity stunts of this century," quips Palomares.

He actively pursued the role of Dali in Hysteria.  "This is not playing another ethnic. I'm playing a character. It's got nothing to do with us in Australia. Salvador Dali is not ethnic. He's Spanish." In fact, he is the quintessential Spaniard. Palomares believes that Dali is almost single-handedly responsible for the Spanish stereotype: the sweeping moustachios, the beret, the arrogance and bravado, the sexually overt behaviour.

"Dali represents ego (in the play). Even when Freud tells Dali his work is rubbish, Dali says 'The world's a whore and you sell it shit.' "

He also epitomises animal impulse and vanity. "When there's a naked woman in the closet, Dali is the one who walks straight in." In fact, all the characters in the play are manifestations of Freudian theory. Jessica is the instinct, Freud's Id. Yahuda, Freud's doctor in the play, is a composite character based on a real Rabbi and Freud's physician, represents the social conscience, the Superego.

After reading Dali's biography, Palomares is convinced that Dali and Gala "were ruthless with people they met. They only talked to the people who would benefit them."

Dali was a big old show-off, a shameless self-promoter, a marketing expert before it became fashionable, and a relentless opportunist. With his formidable talent and personality, he is the ultimate representation of Ego in 20th century culture.

KATE HERBERT

Wednesday, 15 June 1994

To Pave by Ecorche Theatre, REVIEW, 15 June 1994

At Courthouse Theatre, Carlton

Until June 25, 1994

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 15  June 1994.

This review published in The Melbourne Times after 15 June 1994

 

To Pave, directed by dancer-choreographer Alison Halit, constructs some witty and evocative physical images involving bricks and people. The three actor-dancers perform with, and are often upstaged by, a proliferation of white bricks. "Never do a show with children, animals or bricks."

 

The performers pile bricks on themselves and each other, construct cairns, pillars, walls, sculptures, cars, supermarkets. They prance, dance, leap and balance precariously on piles of bricks. My favourite image was of a woman trying to relax on a random pile of bricks. The danger of moving through and tossing (yes, tossing) bricks, becomes part of the drama.

 

In fact, it is the dramatic content. When the performers spoke, the piece lost all its impact. The dialogue was trite, repetitive and the acting pedestrian. The bricks generally had more weight than the performers.

 

To Pave feels like a workshop script. The unintegrated collage of styles is at its most successful without speech but with action choreographed over a dynamic and professional musical backing by Benedict Deane-Johns. The movement is generally clever, abstract and lyrical and the dancers competent, but there are a couple of crashingly melodramatic and romantic dance sequences.

 

Although this is a non-narrative piece, the three performers play two-dimensional characters. Sylvia (Vivenne Lucas), a self-centred artist, prepares an installation. Track (Adrian Nunes) studies medicine and cheats on his exams. Tracey, (Corinne Larkins) a working mother, supports the other two. They juggle their lives and each other just as they symbolically juggle bricks. All the naturalistic stuff is extraneous. It is great when it sticks to the action.

by Kate Herbert

 

The Sisters Rosensweig by Wendy Wasserstein, MTC, REVIEW, 15 June 1994

THEATRE
The Sisters Rosensweig by Wendy Wasserstein

By Melbourne Theatre Company

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 15 June 1994.

This review published in The Melbourne Times after15b June 1994

 

“Very funny. Some great lines." This comment I heard from all quarters whilst eavesdropping during the interval of The Sisters Rosensweig.

 

US writer, Wendy Wasserstein, writes a great gag. " Gender is mainly spare parts," quips the waggish bisexual theatre director, and there are plenty more one-liners to come.

 

Wasserstein's script is no masterpiece and is too long, but it is light and gently amusing and, yet again, director Roger Hodgman has done some inspired casting.

 

Sarah, (Judy Farr) an expatriate American Jew living in London, invites her two sisters (Genevieve Picot, Jackie Weaver) to her birthday dinner. In the first act the three seem disconnected, dissimilar and discordant (to use a few "d" words) but, by the second half, their bond is palpable. The trio is based on Wasserstein and her own successful sisters.

 

Picot is vulnerable and brittle as youngest sister Pfeni, a journalistic wandering Jew who is in love with an errant gentile bisexual, Geoffrey, played energetically and with wicked humour, by Tony Sheldon. Weaver is wonderfully brazen as Gorgeous, the loud, gushy, overdressed middle sister who is completely shameless about her role as a radio psychologist with no qualifications. Only in America.

 

There are strong support performances from Rachel Griffiths as Sarah's daughter and Gerard Lepkowski as her boyfriend Tom, the Lithuanian Liverpool Jew.

 

Farr exudes a regal melancholy as Sarah. Her dislocation and self-inflicted exile are pivotal. She prefers a country "where feelings are openly repressed." The play seems to be about expatriatism but emerges as a story of the struggle of these three women to deal with separation: from each other, from their country, culture, family and their dead but ever-present mother.  Eventually it is clear that the notion of Jewishness and identity is less important than their search for love and security.

 

Through pure snobbishness, Sarah resists the persistent advances of Mervyn, (Max Gillies) the furrier who came in from the cold London night. She prefers the snotty Nicholas Pym (Ron Challinor) to the effervescent and warm Merv. The play began slowly but paced up when the highly-charged Sheldon appeared, followed by an irrepressible Weaver.

 

The production has tempered even the most stridently New York-Jewish of the characters. This has somehow lessened its impact. The humour is New York Jewish and loses something without the associated throw away, self-deprecating style. Wasserstein satirises her own community. To paraphrase, "What? Another Jew who raises the holocaust 30 seconds into the conversation?"

By Kate Herbert

Friday, 10 June 1994

Taming of the Shrew, Bell Shakespeare, June 1994


Taming of the Shrew
By Bell Shakespeare 
Comedy Theatre till June, 1994
Reviewed by KATE HERBERT
Published in The Melbourne Times, June 1994

I am compelled to love John Bell's production of The Taming of the Shrew, not merely because the Shrew in question is named Kate. It is a brazen, bawdy and hilarious interpretation with more front than Daimaru.

Bell has grabbed the comedy baton and run with it. All the personages are broad clowns accentuated by Stephen Curtis's bold costumes. Kate and Petruchio are Brunswick Street groovers in black leather and grunge gear, Grumio,
Petruchio's servant is a cunning and cheeky punk, his other servants are a bunch of thugs, pimps and hippies.

The most courageous and wonderful choice is to play the sweet chaste and ever boring Bianca as a cheap bimbo. Of course! She gets all the suitors because she's the town bike!

This is a strong ensemble. Christopher Stollery is a very inviting and modern Petruchio. Essie Davis plays a spunky, spitfire Kate. Darren Gilshennen as Grumio is a wild low-life and with Stollery makes a great double act doing Three Stooges slapstick.  The comic detail is a delight. Petruchio carries his dad's ashes around in an urn.

Of course everybody wonders about the feminist politics of The Shrew in 1994. Davis's Kate relinquishes her stroppiness to participate in her husband's taunting of others. Stollery is relieved when she finally catches on to the game. The earnestness of Kate's final speech about the dutious wife has none of the sense of mockery and becomes a bit schmaltzy. Kate's shrewishness, rather than being tamed, has turned to lustiness but there is little sexual tension when Petruchio says admiringly, "What a wench. Kiss me Kate."

The style's derivation is clearly Vaudeville. The pre-show entertainment is a (purposely) bad Russian psychic and a terribly earnest tap dancer (unintentionally?). Musician David King is on stage in a rising gold painted rostrum playing trashy musak. The cheap and tacky quality continues with Michael Scott-Mitchell's set of nasty pink reception tables at the wedding, and kitsch pile of chintzy furniture and car parts which passes as Petruchio's pad.

Bell's  Shrew is really in your face. This is exhilarating, knee slappin', belly laughin' theatre you must see - even if you hate Shakespeare.

By Kate Herbert

Wednesday, 8 June 1994

The Yellow Wallpaper by Amanda Armstrong , La Mama, REVIEW, 8 June 1994

THEATRE 

The Yellow Wallpaper by Amanda Armstrong

At La Mama till June 19, 1994

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 8 June 1994

This review was published in The Melbourne Times after 8 June 1994

 

Temporary nervous depression, a slight hysterical tendency" describes the condition suffered by the woman in The Yellow Wallpaper. There is more hysteria in this production than depression.

 

The play is adapted by actor, Amanda Armstrong and director, Fille Dusseljee from a story by early feminist, Charlotte Perkins Gilman. It attempts to abstract and physicalise the mental state of the woman.

 

Armstrong is alone in the La Mama space just as the woman is in her wallpapered room. She obsesses about her wallpaper design which is peopled with "creeping women" trying to escape. The symbolism is obvious: the woman is incarcerated in her own mind, in her own room by her husband, in her illness.

 

The story has great potential for exploring mental illness, compulsive behaviour and disorientation, but the performance remains unintentionally unsympathetic. Dusseljee has created a very physical style with some interesting moments but it is disconnected from the text and often feels uncomfortable and arbitrary.

 

Sound features strongly. There is a haunting and evocative soundscape by Guy Hancock and Armstrong's singing voice is moving and resonant in a way which is lacking in the dialogue.

 

The play, however, has a rather contrived and jarring dynamic. It seems to use either accelerator or brake, mute button or full volume. The final ten minutes seemed to find a balance, to surprise and disturb whereas the rest was too obvious. The symbolism is overstated where mental illness is much more subtle.

 

Madness is timeless. People suffer now as they always have. Perhaps we now have too sophisticated an understanding of it from pop psychology to tolerate a simplistic interpretation.

 

KATE HERBERT

Thursday, 2 June 1994

Shadowboxing by James Gaddas, REVIEW, 2 June 1994

 

THEATRE

At Napier Street Theatre till 12 June, 1994

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 2 June 1994

This review was published in The Melbourne Times after 2 June 1994

 

Witnessing male violence on stage can feel like a personal assault. It makes women particularly, feel unsafe. The extraordinary thing about Shadowboxing, James Gaddas' witty and well-observed play about a young pugilist, is that the boxer is almost palpably the victim of his own violence.

 

The play is very intimate. Robert Morgan is on stage alone as "Erroll" Flynn, the boxer. We are his confidantes and voyeurs who watch his personal struggle to overcome his father's failure as a fighter, to find dignity and a clear identity in both the boxing arena and the world at large. Discovering you're gay in the macho world of fighters is dangerous.

 

The production is wildly, frenetically physical. Morgan, a former boxer himself, is on his feet "dancing", skipping, and punching words at us from go to whoa. Bruce Myles direction is inspiring and dynamic, using the rhythm of the fight and lighting by Glenn Hughes is simple and dramatic.

 

 This poor bastard is seeking some tenderness from the world, knowing there is a softness somewhere beneath his violent exterior - but the world will not allow him to soften.

 

Shadowboxing is emotionally and physically exhausting, but it is under an hour. The journey is like a rocket launch; starts slow and then blows the top off your head. Go see!

 

By Kate Herbert

Warriors by Peter Murphy, REVIEW, 2 June 1994

 THEATRE

At Napier Street until 12 June 1994

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 2 June 1994

This review was published in The Melbourne Times after 2 June 1994

 

Men are having a personal growth spurt, there's no doubt about it. Some elements of the Men's Movement are simply Backlashing against Feminism, but others are just trying to overcome their emotional bankruptcy by getting in touch - with everything.

 

Peter Murphy's reworked solo play, Warriors, is one man's deep and personal probings into his own psyche as he prepares for the funeral of his son. It is an intense, touching and, at times very funny, e, although at times the performance lacks attack.

 

Murphy rattles around Napier Street Theatre with just one chair as a prop. The hollow space makes the character more vulnerable, glazed and fragile in his profound grief. He talks about the practical affairs of parenting and tells anecdotes about his son to distract himself from his pain. These remind him of his own childhood: his drunken father, his mother's sudden abandonment of the family, being caught masturbating.

 

He reminisces about missing his son's birth because he was in a drunken stupor in a motel room. He recalls trying to have sex for the first time after the birth and his wife falling asleep, so he watched Diehard on TV and clattered around the house pissed off.

 

What is so charming about this show is the directness and honesty of the character. He is an ordinary bloke who is bemused and confused by his own life and the mystery of humanity but wants to understand.

 

By KATE HERBERT

 

Sunday, 22 May 1994

Doing the Block by John Romeril, Arena Theatre Company, 22 May 1994

THEATRE

By Arena Theatre Company

At Arena Theatre Studio till June 1994

Reviewer: Kate Herbert around 22 May 1994

This review was published in The Melbourne Times after 22 May 1994

 

John Romeril has written a very warm, sensitive and politically informed script directed by David Carlin for Arena Theatre. "This century has made us all gypsies " says one character. Migration, refugeeism and fast travel have moved us out of our familiar environments and we are all coping with change beyond our capacities.

 

Romeril effectively links two stories. One about Nam (Kha Viet Tran) who against his mother's wishes goes back to Vietnam seeking his ancestors even though he was born here. The second story is about a young Hispano-Australian (Carmen Mascia) and her newly discovered uncle (Petru Gheorghiu) who has a mental illness resulting from the torture he suffered in Argentina.

 

Romeril's ironic sense of the absurdity of political abuses is evident in the uncle's comment to Nam's Vietnamese mother (Min Ha). "You fled the communists. I was tortured for being one."

 

The linking character is a very generous and charming Koori welfare worker (Tom E. Lewis) who attends everybody's needs but his own but his "clients" look after him in the end.

 

This production is musical, and the dearth of quality voices is compensated for by the commitment to the social and political content. Live music composed by Irene Vela runs under the action, giving emotional layers to the scenes. Songs weave in and out of dialogue, stories link and interact like an operatic score. At one point as the song moves between household, the style imperceptibly alters from Flamenco to Vietnamese.

 

Trina Parker has cleverly designed a scaffold set representative of the Richmond flats.

 

The problem in this production is that the actors seem to be strolling around the cavernous space much of the time. Trian Parker’scaffolding set representative of the Richmond flats is cleverly designed, but the play is much stronger when songs are choreographed tightly and scenes are emotionally changed. Some of the performances have little dramatic and emotional depth but the text assists them.

 

KATE HERBERT